Skip to content
Health Advocates Call for Transparency and Accountability After Plasma Donor Deaths

Health Advocates Call for Transparency and Accountability After Plasma Donor Deaths

A close‑up photo shows a gloved health care worker holding a syringe filled with red blood near a donor’s arm during a plasma collection procedure. Overlaid text reads, “Health advocates call for transparency and accountability after plasma donor deaths,” with a U Radio News logo in the top right corner.
Canadian health advocates are calling for transparency, accountability, and an end to for‑profit plasma collection after paid donor deaths in Winnipeg raised concerns about safety, regulation, and profit‑driven incentives.

Health care advocates from across Canada are renewing calls to end for‑profit plasma collection and bring the system fully into public control, following the deaths of two paid plasma donors in Winnipeg and mounting evidence of regulatory non‑compliance at private clinics operated by multinational giant Grifols.

At a media conference this week, coalitions representing patients, labour, and public health care advocates emphasized that the issue goes beyond isolated incidents, pointing instead to structural problems tied to profit‑driven plasma collection. Noah Schulz, director of the Manitoba Health Coalition, argued that transparency and accountability are essential to restoring public trust and preventing further harm.

“I have been director of Manitoba Health Coalition for just a year now and come into this tradition that other health coalitions have really been part of, which is opposing the profit motive within health care, including how it can have perverse incentives within plasma collection in particular,” Schulz said.

Schulz located current concerns within a longer Canadian history shaped by the tainted blood scandal of the 1980s and 1990s. Referencing the Krever Commission, he stressed its “central recommendation that the blood supply, plasma supply, be kept voluntary, because this is the safest thing for donors and for the blood supply as a whole.”

Health Canada has completed its assessment of the two recent Winnipeg deaths and stated that they were not linked to the plasma donation process. “Its assessment found no evidence of a machine malfunction and the equipment performed as expected,” Health Canada spokesperson Mark Johnson wrote, adding that reviews consider “the timing of events, cause of death, medical history and any incidents during the plasma collection.”

Even so, Schulz said the findings leave critical questions unanswered. “Any death is unacceptable in this kind of context. We don’t want people dying, whether it is in the process of donating plasma or blood, or in receiving it as lifesaving measures.”

Three people in Manitoba have died after giving plasma over the past decade, according to Health Canada, all linked to for‑profit collection sites. Schulz contrasted that record with the public system. “In contrast to that, Canadian Blood Services and other public, non-profit ways of donating, plasma or blood have caused no deaths.”

He also raised concerns about enforcement, noting repeated Health Canada citations against Grifols’ facilities across the country. “We just don’t see the regulations and the conditions that Grifols is meant to follow being enforced well enough,” he said, describing recent federal requirements as “basic safety conditions… that should be the baseline, not a reactive set of conditions that are only put on after people have died.”

A key demand from advocates is greater transparency, including a full public inquest into the Winnipeg deaths. “We need that fulsome investigation… to make sure that public trust is well earned and is restored in this case,” Schulz said.

He also called for disclosure of the contract between Canadian Blood Services and Grifols, arguing the public deserves to know “how much profit is being made in this process.”

Those concerns were echoed by other speakers, who warned that secrecy, weak enforcement, and economic pressure on vulnerable donors undermine safety, and that Schultz and others have more questions.

– Ryan Funk, U Multicultural


Inspection Report Cards

Share this post with your friends

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

U Multicultural
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.