As an initiative from the Immigration Partnership Winnipeg (IPW), the “Anti-Racism in Sport” campaign seeks to increase, promote and engage discussions on the impact of all levels of racism in athlete’s lives, including Black, Indigenous and religious minorities. “It approaches how we’re going to address, disrupt and eliminate discrimination and
Breaking Down Barriers for LGBTQ+ Trafficking Victims
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not
necessarily reflect the official policy or position of U Multicultural.
The sex trafficking victims that are part of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, or questioning (LGBTQ+) community often face a lack of resources to help them out of forced sex and violence. Along with this, they are also victims of the problematic law enforcement that does not identify them as victims, but as criminals. There is also a barrier of understanding with LGBTQ+ victims, as they are conceptualized to not be exploitable compared to cisgender women; thus, research and data on this group are limited in this area of the topic. This makes one’s need for education on this community’s involvement in trafficking to be almost inaccessible to fulfill.
Societal Discrimination as the Primary Cause
The “why” of the problem roots from the injustice system for persons of this community. Primarily, their inability to access employment and basic resources such as healthcare is due to the hostility of potential employers and society as a whole when realizing their gender identification. Polaris Project is a nonprofit organization in the United States that recognizes this community as susceptible victims to trafficking: “[y]outh who identify as [LGBTQ+] often face discrimination and homelessness – two factors that make them especially vulnerable to traffickers.”
Homelessness is a big factor in LGBTQ+ victims’ involvement in trafficking, because they are disqualified from jobs due to society’s misperception of two “appropriate” genders. From the Journal of Human Trafficking, “scholars have linked pervasive employment discrimination trans people commonly face to engaging in sex work as a survival strategy.” Although sex work is not to be confused with human trafficking, this is the risky gateway for persons of the LGBTQ+ community to unintentionally become involved in horrific psychological and sexual acts for no income.
The Paradoxical Law Enforcement
A skewed concept that has been legally established is the inability to recognize victims of the LGBTQ+ community, namely trans victims who identify as women. “The invisibility of trans people among recognized victims of trafficking is rooted in the Palermo Protocol’s implied characterization of the ideal trafficking victims as a cisgender women and exacerbated by the anti-trafficking movement’s persistent failure to recognize trans women as women.”
Thus, the sad reality of victim blaming becomes the rescue tactic. Not only are victims locked in the psychological trauma that was their reality while being trafficked, but they are now literally imprisoned with criminal offences of “participating” in the illegal sex trade. “When they manage to break free of trafficking situations, they often still face substantial barriers including lack of appropriate social services and discrimination within the criminal justice system.” Consequently, victims find it difficult to embed in normal civilization and find themselves as targets in trafficking again.
Inclusivity as a Resolution
In order to overcome the problem of LGBTQ+ members as being indefensible in this issue, there needs to be bigger solutions in place. Fundamentally, the laws in place should alter to fit them as victims in the victim paradigm, and not enacting a criminal offence. Not only will this eliminate ignorance, but it will recognize LGBTQ+ as targets, assuring more research in this area. What is more, basic resources such as housing and employment should be extended to LGBTQ+ members to decrease discrimination. Lastly, there should be organizations that focuses on reaching out to LGBTQ+ victims of human trafficking. “In particular, participants [find] services with a health or legal focus particularly useful, and they prefer organizations specifically designed or run by other [members of their group] where they [feel] more respected and accepted.”
Should you find yourself in a situation to actively help a victim, call 911 or Crime Stoppers: 204-786-8477 in Winnipeg or 1-800-222-8577 toll-free. To speak to a counsellor as someone affected by human trafficking, call Klinic’s 24/7 human trafficking hotline: 1-844-333-2211.
Anne E. Fehrenbacher, Jennifer Musto, Heidi Hoefinger, Nicola Mai, P.G. Macioti, Calogero Giametta & Calum Bennachie (2020) Transgender People and Human Trafficking: Intersectional Exclusion of Transgender Migrants and People of Color from Anti- trafficking Protection in the United States, Journal of Human Trafficking, 6:2, 182-194, DOI: 10.1080/23322705.2020.1690116
Polaris. 2020. Breaking Barriers: Improving Services For LGBTQ+ Human Trafficking Victims. [online] Available at: <https://polarisproject.org/resources/breaking-barriers-improving-services-for-lgbtq-human-trafficking-victims/> [Accessed 26 September 2020].
Wikipedia.org. 2020. Protocol To Prevent, Suppress And Punish Trafficking In Persons, Especially Women And Children. [online] Available at: <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protocol_to_Prevent,_Suppress_and_Punish_Trafficking_in_Persons,_Especially_Women_and_Children> [Accessed 2 October 2020].
Authored by Natasha Byrne
From the National Turtle Lodge Council of Elders and Knowledge Keepers In Partnership with the National Centre for Truth and Reconciliation TURTLE LODGE, SAGKEENG FIRST NATION, MANITOBA – Elders, Knowledge Keepers, and Youth Helpers from many different Nations across our homeland gathered from July 14-16, 2021 at the Turtle Lodge
Mother Patricia Yassie never expected a devastating event to happen to her again. “I never expected when my son said bye, that was going to be my last time seeing my son.” On Sunday, July 4, 17-year-old Jaden Charles John Oman was murdered in an assault, allegedly at the hands
Although COVID-19 has caused uncertainty about events and festivals, the International Reggae Afro Latin Music & Arts Festival is going live. IRAL Festival has decided to host a virtual party on July 10, featuring Caribbean, Latin and African music and dancing showcased by talented local performers. The event is free
Warning: This post contains details some readers may find distressing. On May 27, the First Nations community was shaken when the remains of 215 First Nations children were found in unmarked graves on what was once a Catholic-run Residential School in Kamloops, B.C. Some of the children were as young
On May 27, the First Nations community was shaken when the remains of 215 First Nations children were found in unmarked graves on what was once a Catholic-run Residential School in Kamloops, B.C. Some of the children were as young as three years old. According to the Truth and Reconciliation